PH323: W1A2: Feedback

FEEDBACK:

You will find my feedback for your W1A2 for two out of the three categories in the rubric; details for peer responses will be noted in the gradebook. 

Feedback has been provided to you in the form of “video feedback”.  The video is located above (just below the assignment's rubric).  Please ensure that you watch the entire length of the video in order to gain the most insight and to take note of which images I've pointed out as "top shots".

  • RE: SUBMITTED 3 TOP IMAGES USING 1 SUBJECT IN 3 DIFFERENT GENRES OF PORTRAITURE THAT
    • HAVE CORRECT EXPOSURE, DEMONSTRATE TECHNICAL KNOWLEDGE OF CAMERA & LIGHTING CONTROL
    • EXHIBIT CREATIVITY WITH ANGLES & COMPOSITION (MOVING CAMERA AND SUBJECT FREQUENTLY TO EXPLORE THE ANGLES)
    • SHOW ATTENTION TO COMPOSITION AND DESIGN ELEMENTS
    • FOLLOWED INSTRUCTIONS AND REQUIREMENTS IN ASSIGNMENT
You submitted 3 top images that represent your chosen 3 sub-genres of portraiture, although I've pointed out a few "suggested top" images within the group video critique. 

In terms of lighting, exposure, technical knowledge of camera and strobe lighting: I made a few suggestions within the group video critique for how to improve. When working with strobe lights, ensure that your ISO is set to 100 and that your shutter speed is slower than 1/200th of a second. Details as to why are noted in the group video critique; I also point out a few posts in the Questions for the Professor section that go over these topics.  You'll also hear me discuss that all students are encouraged to position subject at least 6 feet in front of backdrop. 

Student's composition was handled well and is encouraged to continue to "push" composition; avoid cropping subject's off at edge of frame; continue to shoot from a variety of angles.  Moving forward: try to block your subject's face less and also avoid cropping subject off at the edge of the frame. Student is encouraged to review the posts in the Questions for the Professor section regarding composition.
  • RE: POSTED A CONTACT SHEET CONTAINING A MINIMUM OF 45 (15 PER GENRE) PHOTOGRAPHS AND INCLUDED 150 WORD EXPLANATION ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHIC PROCESS AND PORTRAIT GENRE
All three of your chosen sub-genres (editorial, character, advertising) visually met the requirements; well done! I was glad to see that you include your images of your handheld light meter and wide-angle image of how your lights and modifiers were positioned. Further details on how to improve are noted in the video critique.

Student's written statement was handled well; discussed both the technical and creative choices made throughout the shoot.  Statement met the 200-word mark; student is encouraged to use Microsoft Word to ensure the proper length of all entries. 


 
Keep up the hard work and feel free to get in touch if you have any questions or concerns.
-Prof. F